Here is my formal Submission to the University of Sydney’s 2019 research-integrity inquiry, forced by the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) after I raised concerns about another faulty diet-and-health paper: https://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/USyd-Misconduct-June19.pdf
In my Submission, I set out 60 clear, readily verifiable claims. Neither my claims nor evidence are complicated. Proper assessment requires merely competence and honesty. Without further ado, I encourage each of you to assess my 60 claims (beginning on page 3 in the link above).
Notably, Professor Stephen Simpson is both the senior author of the latest dodgy paper and the Academic Director of the Charles Perkins Centre, the influential manager who has protected Professor Jennie Brand-Miller’s Australian Paradox sugar-and-obesity fraud, and in 2017 oversaw its dishonest expansion into the American Journal Of Clinical Nutrition (pp. 5-6 in link above).
Here is the University of Sydney newspaper Honi Soit’s initial report on the new research-integrity inquiry: https://honisoit.com/2019/06/peak-medical-research-body-asks-usyd-to-investigate-concerns-2/
RESEARCH MISCONDUCT AT THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY – WHAT IS TO BE DONE?
Hi there and welcome. My name is Rory Robertson. This website documents a disturbing lack of competence and integrity at the highest levels of nutrition science in Australia.
My documentation of the University of Sydney’s Australian Paradox sugar-and-obesity fraud can be tracked through the PDF documents that run down the left-hand side of the screen. It’s been a bit of an epic: I have been highly ineffective in trying to fix this mess since 2012.
If you read some of my work below and think I have a strong point, maybe you will write to the University of Sydney or, better still, someone influential who will press Vice-Chancellor Michael Spence to stop defrauding taxpayers of $700 million per year with false promises of “research excellence”.
In 2019, the Charles Perkins Centre at the University of Sydney – home of the Australian Paradox fraud – has been found to be misrepresenting diet-and-longevity matters in another high-profile paper that does not withstand basic scrutiny.
Some of my best work is highlighted below:
- Expression of Concern regarding misrepresented mouse-diet results in high-profile University of Sydney paper: https://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/Letter-cell-metabolism.pdf
- Scientific fraud “red alert” after Sydney University’s false denial of longevity misrepresentation in faulty Cell Metabolism paper: https://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/Letters-USyd-Cell-Metabolism.pdf
- ABC’s secret investigation into Australian Paradox matters confirms serious scientific fraud: https://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/ABC-investigation-AustralianParadox.pdf
- Professor Jennie Brand-Miller’s academic misconduct spreads to Australian National University: http://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/USyd-Misconduct-in-ANU-PhD.pdf
- Here’s me, Emma Alberici and ABC TV’s Lateline on the University of Sydney’s Australian Paradox: http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2015/s4442720.htm
- Here’s my Five-year Update on the Australian Paradox fraud, including Vice-Chancellor Spence’s threat to ban me from campus: p. 64 http://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/Big-5-year-update-Feb-2017.pdf
- During National Diabetes Week 2016, I wrote to the Department of Health about “The scandalous mistreatment of Australians with type 2 diabetes (T2D)”: http://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/Expanded-Letter-HealthDept-type2diabetes.pdf
Want to stop trends in your family and friends towards obesity, type 2 diabetes, heart disease and various cancers? Stop eating and drinking sugar: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDaYa0AB8TQ&feature=youtu.be
Here’s the diet advised by Dr Peter Brukner, recently the Australian cricket team’s doctor: http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf ; http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/lowcarb/
Charlie Perkins was born in Alice Springs near the red centre of Australia in June 1936. I was born there 30 years later in March 1966.
I dedicate this body of work on the Charles Perkins Centre’s Australian Paradox sugar-and-obesity fraud and Cell Metabolism’s mouse-diet-and-human-health deception to my mother, Elaine Lucas, who nursed Aboriginal and other Australians in remote places – including Katherine, Alice Springs, Balcanoona and Woorabinda – from the 1960s to the 1980s. And to my late father, Alexander Robertson (see link below), who grew up in Scotland and in the Scots Guards then shifted to Coogee in Sydney before working with cattle and sheep across country Australia for half a century, and taught me, often by example, much about what is right and much about what is wrong.
I also have firmly in mind people like Bonita and Eddie Mabo, Faith Bandler, Charlie Perkins (who Dad says he knew briefly, and so too his brother Ernie, in The Territory over half a century ago), Waverley Stanley and Lou Mullins of Yalari, and especially Noel Pearson, all of whom worked or are working indefatigably for decades to improve the lot of their peoples left behind.
Finally, I wonder whatever happened to the many Aboriginal boys and girls I met across country Australia when I was a boy, including those with whom I shared classrooms and sports fields back in Baralaba (central Queensland) in the late 1970s. Much of the news over the years has been tragic and depressing. https://www.australianparadox.com/baralaba.htm
Please note: In this and other documents, I have detailed influential incompetence and worse in nutrition and health “science”, and by Group of Eight university senior management. Importantly, if you read anything here or elsewhere from me that is factually incorrect or otherwise unreasonable, please contact me immediately and, if I agree, I will correct the text as soon as possible.
This all matters because more than one million Australians today have type 2 diabetes, the number growing rapidly. Many of these vulnerable consumers can expect mistreatment, misery and early death, harmed by high-carbohydrate diabetes advice promoted by a range of respected entities advised by highly influential Group of Eight science careerists. The unfolding diabetes tragedy can be seen most clearly in the quiet suffering of short-lived Indigenous Australians.
A life in our times: Vale Alexander “Sandy” Robertson (1933-2015): http://www.australianparadox.com/pdf/AlecRobertson-born2oct33.pdf
Strathburn Cattle Station is a proud partner of YALARI, Australia’s leading provider of quality boarding-school educations for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander teenagers. Check it out at http://www.strathburn.com/yalari.php
Comments, criticisms, questions, compliments, whatever welcome at firstname.lastname@example.org
WHAT EXACTLY IS THE AUSTRALIAN PARADOX “FINDING”, AND WHAT’S NOT TO LIKE?
The authors’ summary of the available evidence is very specific: “This analysis of apparent consumption, national dietary surveys and food [beverage] industry data indicates a consistent and substantial decline in total refined or added sugar consumption by Australians over the past 30 years [1980 to 2010]”.
Yes, very specific and also absolutely false. Clearly, the authors’ “finding” is contradicted by Figures 1-4 below; that is, four of the authors’ own published charts – each showing a valid if imperfect indicator of per-capita sugar consumption – trend up not down in the 1980-2010 timeframe.
Source: Australian Paradox Revisited; My trend scratched in for “the past 30 years”
Source: Australian Paradox ; My mark is the 2004 (not 2003) “peak” in sugary softdrinks
Source: Australian Paradox
economist and former-fattie
Strathburn Cattle Station is a proud partner of YALARI, Australia’s leading provider of quality boarding-school educations for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander teenagers.Check it out at http://www.strathburn.com/yalari.php